top of page

Are Vinyl Tire Covers Better Than Fabric? Real Comparison

  • Writer: Marko S.
    Marko S.
  • Dec 3
  • 3 min read

Are Vinyl Tire Covers Better Than Fabric?

When choosing a spare tire cover, the biggest decision is which material to buy: vinyl or fabric. Both are common, but they perform very differently once exposed to sun, rain, heat, and real outdoor conditions.


Most cheap imported covers are made from thin fabric or lightweight PVC. Quality covers — like SpareCover® — use marine-grade vinyl designed for long-term durability.


Here’s a full breakdown of vinyl vs fabric tire covers, and which one gives your spare the protection it actually needs.


Vinyl Tire Covers: Durable, Weather-Proof, and Long-Lasting

Vinyl is the industry standard for a reason. High-quality marine-grade vinyl offers:

  • Excellent UV resistance

  • Better fade protection

  • Strong weather resistance

  • Long lifespan

  • A smooth, clean appearance

  • Easy cleaning and maintenance

  • Tight, form-fitting stretch

  • High durability in sun, rain, and snow


Most professional-grade tire covers — including SpareCover® — use heavy marine-grade vinyl, the same material used in outdoor marine environments.


Vinyl is simply built to survive outside.


Fabric Tire Covers: Lightweight but Not Made for Sun or Weather

Fabric covers are often made from:

  • Polyester

  • Nylon

  • Canvas-like materials


While they may feel soft or look casual, fabric tire covers have major weaknesses:

  • They absorb moisture

  • They fade extremely fast

  • They grow mildew or mold

  • They tear easily in wind

  • They break down under UV exposure


Fabric covers work only in mild indoor conditions — not on a spare tire exposed to sun, heat, or rain.


UV Resistance: Vinyl Wins by a Large Margin

Sunlight is the #1 cause of tire damage.

Vinyl offers real UV protection — fabric does not.

Marine-Grade Vinyl:

  • Contains UV inhibitors

  • Resists bleaching

  • Maintains color for years

  • Prevents sun damage to the tire underneath


Fabric Covers:

  • Fade within weeks

  • Bleach unevenly

  • Become weak and brittle

  • Offer little to no UV protection


If your spare tire is on the rear of your vehicle, UV resistance is essential.


Weather Protection: Vinyl Is Waterproof — Fabric Is Not

Vinyl Tire Covers:

  • Waterproof

  • Block rain and snow

  • Prevent moisture penetration

  • Protect against road salt

  • Stay strong in wind and storms


Fabric Covers:

  • Absorb water

  • Stay wet for hours

  • Develop mildew

  • Freeze in winter

  • Become heavy and sag


Water + fabric = early failure.


Fit and Appearance: Vinyl Looks Better and Stays Tight

Vinyl covers provide a smooth, tailored look.

Fabric covers often look loose, wrinkled, or baggy.


Vinyl:

  • Holds shape

  • Stretches evenly around the tire

  • Maintains a clean, OEM-style appearance


Fabric:

  • Wrinkles

  • Flaps in the wind

  • Looks worn quickly

  • Loses tension over time



If you want a clean, professional look, vinyl is the clear winner.

Lifespan: Vinyl Lasts Years — Fabric Often Lasts Months

Fabric covers rarely survive a full season of real weather.

Vinyl, especially marine-grade, can last for years.

Fabric Lifespan:

  • Weeks to months

  • Very short if exposed to daily sun

  • Tears easily in wind


Marine-Grade Vinyl Lifespan:

  • Years of outdoor use

  • Withstands harsh climates

  • Maintains color and strength

This is why nearly all quality tire covers are vinyl.



Why SpareCover® Only Uses Marine-Grade Vinyl

SpareCover products are built to last with:

  • U.S.-made marine vinyl

  • UV-resistant print technology

  • Reinforced stitching

  • Heavy-duty elastic retention

  • Excellent weather durability


Fabric covers can’t provide reliable protection, especially for rear-mounted spares on:

  • Jeep Wrangler

  • Ford Bronco

  • Toyota RAV4

  • Honda CR-V

  • FJ Cruiser

  • Hummer H2/H3

  • Land Rover

  • Suzuki/Isuzu SUVs


These spares take full sun and weather exposure — fabric fails quickly.


Final Verdict: Vinyl Is the Best Choice for Spare Tire Protection

If you drive with an exposed spare, a vinyl cover is the only material that provides:

  • UV protection

  • Waterproofing

  • Fade resistance

  • Structural durability

  • Clean appearance

  • Long-term value


Fabric covers cannot compete in any meaningful category.

A marine-grade vinyl SpareCover® gives your tire the protection it needs, keeps your vehicle looking sharp, and lasts dramatically longer than fabric or cheap alternatives.

 
 
 
bottom of page